Research

A stress scenario is a question you typed, not a prediction

A scenario changes an assumption and shows the arithmetic. It does not say the path will happen. False precision is a precise percentage on a story that had no dataset.

Diagram for A stress scenario is a question you typed, not a prediction
Editorial diagram for this note. It is not a data release and it does not plot a market price.

risk1 min readmulti asset

Key points

  • Name the assumption that changed between the two cases.
  • Do not put a probability on the case unless a model and a sample are stated.
  • The lab on this page labels every result as an illustration.

What is going on

Useful comparisons are small. Unlevered versus a larger notional. A half-spread versus a wider one. One holding shocked versus several shocked by the same amount. A 20 percent drawdown versus a 50 percent drawdown, using the recovery identity. Each pair can be recomputed from the inputs. BIS and official education sources discuss stress as a discipline. They do not authorise a website to invent the next crisis path.

Why it matters

A dashboard that ranks scenarios by an unsupported probability looks more finished than a table of assumptions. It is less honest. If the weights do not add up, or the book you typed is smaller than the order, the right output is that fact, not a smoothed price.

What to watch

Keep the two cases identical except for the assumption you meant to change. Write the limitation under the number. Prefer a blank to a borrowed statistic.

Risks

Even a careful scenario misses the risk you did not think to type. That is a reason to keep the list short and the labels plain.

Related

Sources and review

Written by: WiT Markets Editorial. Writes and structures WiT Markets pages. Separates a sourced fact from a cell that is Not confirmed.

Review: Editorially reviewed. This is not a qualified specialist review and it is not a legal sign-off.

Last reviewed: . Next review due . The date is an editorial pass. It is not a live check of every third-party fee.

Other sources

Methodology. Editorial policy. Corrections. Report an error.

A scenario is a question | WiT Markets